St. Augustine School continues in its fine tradition of producing graduating classes of students with high academic caliber. The Class of 2020 was accepted to a broad range of highly selective Catholic High Schools and earned scholarships to 10 schools, including several full tuition scholarships.

In recent years, St. Augustine School's graduating classes have earned upwards of $360,000 to $1,008,260 in academic scholarships to the following schools: Archbishop Stepinac, Dominican Academy, Fordham Preparatory, The Ursuline School, Kennedy Catholic, Maria Regina, Regis, Convent of the Sacred Heart, St. Vincent Ferrer and Iona Preparatory.

Students wishing to attend a Catholic high school take the Test for Admission to Catholic High Schools (TACHS) in November of 8th grade.